More Than a Building: The Story of Gordon M. Crothers Post No. 15
“History is not simply found in old buildings. It is found in the lives of the people who built them.”
Most people drive down Church Avenue in Dade City without giving the old American Legion building a second glance.
To them, it is simply another historic structure in a town filled with history.
A place where veterans meet.
A place where dinners are served.
A place where bingo is played.
An old building.
But if those walls could speak, they would tell a story that began more than a century ago, in a world forever changed by war.
In the spring of 1919, the First World War had finally come to an end.
For the young men of Pasco County, life would never be the same.
Some returned home carrying memories they would never fully share.
Others returned bearing wounds that would remain with them for the rest of their lives.
And some never returned at all.
One of those young men was Private Gordon M. Crothers.
Like so many families of that generation, the Crothers family knew both pride and heartbreak. Gordon answered his country’s call and crossed the Atlantic with the 32nd Division. In the forests and wheat fields of France, he became one of thousands of young Americans who gave their lives so others might live in freedom.
His fellow soldiers came home without him.
They carried something heavier than their duffle bags.
They carried the memory of a friend.
On Memorial Day, May 30, 1919, veterans gathered in Dade City to honor those who would never come home.
That same day, they also turned their thoughts toward the future.
Twenty-eight veterans signed their names to an application that would create one of Florida’s earliest American Legion Posts.
They could have named it after a famous general.
They could have chosen a national hero.
Instead, they looked inward.
They chose one of their own.
Gordon M. Crothers.
That decision tells us something profound about the men who founded this Post.
To them, Gordon was not merely a casualty listed in government records.
He was a friend.
A classmate.
A neighbor.
A young man whose life had been woven into the fabric of Dade City long before the war called him away.
His sacrifice was personal.
And they wanted future generations to remember his name.
The newspaper announcing the organization’s formation listed the officers elected that day.
Commander W. W. Huckabay.
Vice Commander Walter Craig.
Finance Officer Stanley Cochrane.
Sergeant-at-Arms James Ward.
And serving as the first Adjutant was Major Robert B. Sturkie.
At first glance, the title “Adjutant” may seem ordinary.
It was anything but.
Sturkie was a respected attorney, a Florida National Guard officer, and one of the community’s most capable organizers. Again and again, as the years unfolded, his name appeared in newspaper accounts—not because he sought attention, but because he was quietly doing the work that keeps great organizations alive.
He signed the charter application.
He represented the Post at state and national conventions.
He helped guide the purchase of land.
He worked to organize the corporation that would one day build the Legion Home.
When disasters struck, he answered the call.
Long after commander’s terms changed hands, Sturkie remained one of the steady hands guiding the organization forward.
History often remembers presidents and commanders.
Organizations survive because of people like Robert B. Sturkie.
The Post quickly became far more than a veterans’ organization.
The pages of the Dade City Banner tell the story almost week by week.
There were Memorial Day ceremonies.
Armistice Day observances.
Community celebrations.
School programs.
Civic projects.
Meetings held wherever space could be found—homes, restaurants, hotels, and the Woman’s Club.
If you read enough newspapers from the 1920s, something remarkable becomes apparent.
The American Legion wasn’t just participating in community life.
It was helping shape it.
Then, in October 1921, the veterans dreamed bigger.
At a regular Post meeting, forty-five members voted to build a permanent home.
Without hesitation, they pledged one thousand dollars toward the project—a remarkable commitment for a small town only three years removed from war.
Days later they voted to purchase two vacant lots on Church Avenue from A. J. Burnside for five hundred dollars.
The location was carefully chosen.
The lots sat beside the historic Ward House, where one of the charter members lived and where Legion meetings had already been held. Across the years, the founders weren’t simply buying land.
They were planting roots.
Their first plans were modest: a frame building with an assembly hall and several rental rooms to help pay the expenses.
It was practical.
Affordable.
Achievable.
But dreams have a way of growing.
For the next several years, the veterans continued raising money, refining their plans, and patiently waiting for the day when their vision could become reality.
Finally, in 1927, construction began.
The building that rose on Church Avenue was no longer the modest clubhouse envisioned in 1921.
It had become something greater.
It would be built of concrete tile and stucco.
It would include a great meeting hall, a kitchen, rooms for the Women’s Auxiliary, and a massive brick fireplace that still welcomes visitors today.
Most importantly, it would stand as a permanent memorial.
On Armistice Day, November 11, 1927, the people of Dade City gathered once again.
The parade wound through town until it reached a construction site where hundreds assembled.
There, Captain Harvey R. Payne laid the cornerstone of the new Legion Home.
It was more than a construction ceremony.
It was an act of remembrance.
The veterans who had survived the Great War were placing the cornerstone of a building dedicated to those who had not.
Newspaper accounts later described the structure as “a post home and memorial to the World War veterans of Pasco County.”
That single sentence changes everything.
The Post honored Gordon M. Crothers.
The building honored an entire generation.
On January 9, 1928, the dream became reality.
Department officers traveled to Dade City.
The new home was formally dedicated according to the ritual of the American Legion.
The hall echoed with speeches, laughter, music, and hope.
It must have seemed impossible that nearly nine years had passed since those twenty-eight veterans first gathered to organize their Post.
They had built something they believed would outlive them.
They were right.
Their vision was tested almost immediately.
In September 1928, the Okeechobee Hurricane devastated South Florida.
The Legion did not hesitate.
Responding to the call of Department Commander Howard P. McFarland, Gordon M. Crothers Post organized benefit performances, boxing exhibitions, and community fundraising. They sent money south, dispatched volunteers into the disaster zone, and worked alongside the Red Cross and other relief agencies.
Only months after dedicating their new home, they were already fulfilling the purpose for which it had been built.
The building was never intended to serve only veterans.
It was built to serve the community.
Nearly one hundred years have passed.
The founders are gone.
The music from the dedication dance has long faded.
The voices that once filled the great hall have fallen silent.
Yet the building remains.
It still stands exactly where those veterans chose to build it.
It still watches over Church Avenue.
It still welcomes neighbors.
It still reminds us that remembrance is not something we do once a year.
It is something we build into the life of a community.
We cannot shake the hands of Gordon Crothers.
We cannot thank Robert Sturkie for his quiet leadership.
We cannot stand beside James Ward as he lays brick in the great fireplace.
We cannot watch Captain Payne lower the cornerstone into place.
But we can preserve the place where all of those things happened.
That is why this building matters.
Not because it is old.
Not because it is beautiful.
Not even because it belongs to the American Legion.
It matters because it is one of the last tangible links to a generation that believed sacrifice should be remembered, service should continue after the battlefield, and communities are strongest when people choose to build something that will outlive themselves.
That is what stands on Church Avenue today.
It is more than a building.
It is a promise.
A promise made by twenty-eight veterans in 1919.
A promise that has endured for nearly a century.
A legacy worth preserving.
Learn More About Gordon M. Crothers American Legion Post 15
Continue exploring the history and mission of Post 15.